May 5, 1861, The Road from Sumter -24

 
May 5, 1861, The Road from Sumter -24,
“It would be a great political error, not to say a crime, if the Republican President should plunge the New World into war in order to show his attachment to his party or his consistency with his former principles.”
~ London Times
—————————————————————-
Extra session of the Provisional Congress of the Confederate States. Fourth day.
Montgomery, Ala., May 2.
Congress assembled to-day at noon, and, after prayer, the Journals of yesterday were read and confirmed […]
A Resolution of Thanks, to Brigadier General G. T. BEAUERGARD, and the Army under his command, for their conduct in the affair at Fort Sumter.
Be it unanimously Resolved, by the Congress of the Confederate States of America , That the thanks of the people of the Confederates are due, and through this Congress are hereby tendered, to Brigadier General G. T. BEAUEE GARD and his officers, and to the gallant troops of the State of South Carolina, for the skill, fortitude and courage by which they reduced and caused the surrender of Fort Samter, in the harbor of Charleston, on the 12th and 13th days of April, 1861; and the consideration of Congress is also hereby declared of the generosity manifested by their conduct towards a brave and conquered too.
Be is further Resolved, That a copy of this resolution be communicated by the President to GENERAL BEAUREGARD , and through him to the army now under his command.
A Bill to Provide for the Appointment of Chaplains in the Army.
The Congress of the Confederate States of America do enact. That there shall be appointed by the President such number of chaplains, to serve with the army of the Confederate States, during the existing war, as he may deem expedient; and the President shall assign them to such regiments, brigades or posts, as he may deem necessary.– And the appointments made aforesaid shall expire whenever the existing war shall terminate.
SEC. 2. The monthly pay of these captains shall be eighty-five dollars, and such pay shall be in full of all allowances whatever.
—————————————————————
The English Press.
We give extracts, to-day, from the English press. They cry out with one voice against civil war in America. If they pronounce LINCOLN ‘S threats of coercion “diabolical,” what will they say when they hear of the hellish proceedings in New York? We are strongly of opinion that LORD LYONS will be instructed to offer the mediation of England, and, if that is not effectual, that, in the end, the interests of England will require a more effectual intervention.
—————————————————————
A War of Subjugation or Extermination.
An intelligent gentleman [Lord Lyons] who arrived lately in this city, from Washington, states that he heard LINCOLN make a speech on Thursday night last, in which he declared that the present war must end in the subjugation or extermination of the South. That is the purpose of the Administration, beyond all doubt.
—————————————————————
STRATEGICAL POLICY OF THE SOUTHERN CONFEDERACY.
–The New York Journal of Commerce has an editorial upon this subject, in which occurs the following:
Without stopping to inquire further into the nature of the extraordinary rumors in circulation for some time past, in reference to a threatened invasion of the District of Columbia, it is at least safe to suggest as a possible truth, that it has been the persistent policy of the Confederate States, since the first alarm of war, to tempt the North into an enormous scale of expenditure for military purposes, and thus to produce a more speedy exhaustion. It would appear as though no means had been neglected — no artifice unemployed — which might tend to this result. The announced intention of the Confederacy to grant letters of marque, for aught that appears to the contrary, is not likely to be carried into execution; embargoes laid upon commerce at Southern ports have been raised; and Northern vessels seized have been released, in many instances, by direction of the authorities at Montgomery. Nevertheless, these varied acts of hostility may have answered a purpose, by precipitating events in the North, and hastening the final issue. Meanwhile, the Southern States seem to be husbanding their resources in every possible way. Individuals serve in the ranks as common soldiers, gratuitously. Not unfrequently, as the newspapers state, whole companies are put on a war footing, with no other expense to the General Government than the providing of muskets; and railways do the necessary transportation without indemnity.
Reviewing the events of the last few weeks, it may well be doubted whether there has ever been any settled purpose to invade the National Capital. Jefferson Davis evidently prefers to act on the defensive, rather than employ aggressive measures. But even if we accept this as a solution of certain rumors and proceedings otherwise difficult of explanation, it cannot be said that the extensive preparations for the defence of Washington are ill-advised. Without them, the political attitude of two or three of the Border States might have given much more reason for concern; and besides, the concentration of a large force at some convenient point is absolutely necessary.
————————————————————
The British Press on American Affairs.
The American Revolution.
[From the London Times, 19th.]
It needs no comment of ours to impress the public with the great importance of the news from America. We are anxious to speak with caution on this subject, and not cause alarm which may possibly prove to have been unnecessary. Therefore we would rather let the telegraphic summary from Queenstown speak for itself. The steamer left New York on the 6th, and on the day previous the signs of an approaching conflict, which had been visible for some weeks before became so marked that a panic took place in Wall Street. In what may be called the two chief cities of the rival Federations, the belief that war was at hand prevailed equally. In New York there was as we have said, a panic on the Stock Exchange, while from Charleston the telegraph announced that the dreaded moment had arrived, and a rupture would at once take place. It was even feared that military operations had begun on the part of the Southerners. No news had been received from Fort Pickens for several days, and this had led to the belief that the communication had been cut off by the Southern troops. From Charleston it was announced that Major Anderson had been called upon to evacuate Fort Sumter within forty-eight hours, the alternative being that the place would be bombarded. The belief at Washington was that the Government there was as determined as that of the secessionists. Every man had been ordered on duty; frigate, with two first-class merchant steamers, would sail at once with sealed orders, but we learn from a private source that there were still doubts as to whether they were intended to relieve Fort Pickens, or to proceed to St. Domingo.
Such is the momentous intelligence which we publish to-day. We may here, however, repeat the hope so often expressed on this side of the ocean, that if the two sections of the late Union be destined to separation, the change may be accomplished without the spilling of blood. It may, perhaps, be too late to indulge in such wishes, yet we will not give up all hope that even at the last hour moderate counsels may have prevailed, and that this fratricidal war has been checked in the outset. But, supposing that the worst has happened, and, either through the naval operations of the United States or an attack on the Federal forts by their rivals, hostilities have begun, it is plain that a conflict of no common kind must follow. The Confederate States, though without a navy, and consequently forced, for the most part, to remain on the defensive, will be an enemy not easy to deal with. True, they are not so powerful in men or resources as they anticipated some months ago. The fidelity of the border States to the Union has been a great disappointment to the Montgomery politicians and their ambitious President. The Border States, particularly Kentucky and Tennessee, contain a population which, for military purposes, surpasses, perhaps, any in the Union.–The fine race which inhabits these regions would prove formidable enemies to the Government at Washington if they had resolved on seceding. Then there would have been the accession of a large white population without any great admixture of Negroes, and further more considerable wealth, which in the present state of the Southern Exchequer would have been very acceptable. But, though for the present, at least, the Border States stand fast by the Union, yet the South shows a bold front. The seven seceding States, being in earnest and fighting for their independence, have raised an army which the other twenty-seven have not yet succeeded in matching.–According to all accounts, the Southern levies are large, well-disciplined, and in high spirits. For weeks it has been difficult to keep the Charleston regiments from attacking Fort Sumter, and at Pensacola we find that Fort Pickens was hard pressed by a considerable force. The iron foundries in Virginia were turning out guns to be used against the Government which owns the allegiance of Virginia itself. “”Troops, provisions and ammunition were flowing in to the Confederate army,”” was the intelligence received a few days since. It seems clear that, if peace be preserved, it will not be by any yielding on the part of the Secessionists.
It would be a great political error, not to say a crime, if the Republican President should plunge the New World into war in order to show his attachment to his party or his consistency with his former principles. When Mr. Buchanan published his unhappy message — a document to which it is probably owing that South Carolina was followed into secession by six other States–the Republican party, and indeed opinion generally throughout the North, was so much inflamed against the President that Mr. Lincoln found or fancied it necessary to repudiate these sentiments. Incautiously giving utterance to his own opinions wherever he came on his journey from the West, he arrived at Washington pledged not only to keep but to retake the forts belonging to the Union in the seceded States, and to refuse any recognition of Southern independence. The collection of the duties at the Southern ports was also made a part of the new President’s programme. How difficult it has been found to carry out all this, is evident from the long delay which has taken place. Before Mr. Buchanan left office Major Anderson was in extreme danger; no time was to be lost in relieving Fort Pickens and the Confederate States themselves were lowering their tariff and letting in the productions of Europe at a rate which would make every idler in the Border States take to smuggling at once. It was though that the moment Mr. Lincoln was installed a resolution would be taken. But this was not to be. For a full month the President and his Cabinet have been debating what is to be done, and only on the 5th of April is it announced that the policy of coercion has triumphed.
The delay seems all the more to be regretted since confidence among men of business had been almost restored. There was up to nearly the last day of March a feeling that the worst was over, and that, however lamentable might be the disruption of the Republic, there would not be added to this misfortune the still greater calamity of civil war. The absorbing interest in military and political matters was passing away, and business was resuming its usual course. What will be the result of a collision between the two Governments is more than any one can predict. The vision of privateers at sea and partisan bands along the frontier must be so terrible to Americans that it is possible the public feeling of the people may restrain the acts of their rulers. But, should this quarrel begin and continue until both sides are roused into animosity, the war, though short, may be as savage as any that has been carried on even by the Spanish race. The Americans are in the highest degree excitable and vindictive; the ferocity which they carry into their domestic conflicts would be increased largely when one side fancied itself to be resisting tyrants and the other punishing traitors. But we had rather not speculate on so great a calamity as such a war would be. We would rather hope that the good sense of the Americans and the peaceful counsels of this country may bring about a reconciliation before the dispute has been too far envenomed. As long as the two sections of the Union refrain from hostilities, it would be the height of arrogance and folly to interfere; but when the soil and seas of the New World are likely to be stained with blood, foreign nations may surely remonstrate in the cause of humanity.
—————————————————————-
Treachery in Maryland.
The noble State of Maryland has been thus far paralyzed by the treason of GOV. HICKS and HENRY WINTER DAVIS , two matchless political villains who have succeeded in surpassing the infamy of BENEDICT ARNOLD , and inscribing their names in the very lowest and blackest spot in the record of human infamy. If ever men deserved the gallows, each of these traitors to the South deserves to be swung as high as HAMAN . The man who can think of party at a time when the liberty and independence of his State is threatened, is a wretch too vile to live; at any rate, to live among loyal and honest men. If a State falls bravely fighting and doing its best, there is some consolation in the reflection that all the powers God has given it have been employed to the best effect; but to be struck down from its pride of place, to see its ardor dampened, its energies distracted, its resources sapped and mined, by a secret, insidious, interior foe, what can fill a generous soul with such unbearable anguish and humiliation? There are as lofty spirits in Maryland, as gallant and patriotic and generous, as any in the Union; but they have been sold by the HICKSES and DAVISES –sold for the thirty pieces of official silver, which, to ignoble souls, are more precious than honor, duty, Heaven. We by no means despair of Maryland. She cannot be permanently enslaved. She will loosen herself yet from the coil of the serpents and crush their heads beneath her victorious heel.
—————————————————————
Source: Richmond Dispatch by Cowardin & Hammersley, Vol. Xix — no.104 Richmond, Va. Tuesday, may 7, 1861
—————————————————————
Review of events leading up to May 5, 1861:
-80+ years of sectional tensions between northeastern and southeastern states over tariffs, states rights/popular sovereignty, federal power over new territories and most recently, the practice of chattel slavery.
-1857 – Massive Financial Collapse And panic hits Northeastern banks triggered by the sinking sinking of the S.S. Central America carrying 30,000 pounds of gold destined for northern banks.
-A new “Republican” political party is formed with a platform of federal control of new territories, diminishing popular sovereignty, and enforcing new tariffs “by force”, which are all usurpations of the U.S. Constitution.
-The increasing federal debt has lead to a proposed drastic increase in Tariffs that disproportionately effect agricultural southern states as the 48% Morrill Tariffs.
-Radical Republican Leader Thaddeus Stevens, sponsor of the Morrill Tariff, stated: “the Tariff would impoverish the southern and western states, but that was essential for advancing national greatness and the prosperity of [northern] industrial workers.”
-Southeastern states have minority representation in the U.S. Congress due to the 3/5ths rule, which does not allow negro persons to be fully counted for representation.
-Southeastern “Cotton states” protest tariffs, and the fact that these agricultural state are already paying ~75% to 85% of the federal budget with little to none returned in support for infrastructure.
-1859 – John Brown and 18 accomplices began their illegal invasion of Virginia, and murder spree at Harper’s Ferry Virginia, financed by northeastern “abolitionists”.
-November 1860, Abraham Lincoln is selected as U.S. President with a minority of the popular vote and was not even on the ballot in 10 states, with a pledge to institute the new party’s platform, by force if necessary.
-The seven “cotton states” that are most impacted by the new 48% Morrill Tariffs begin secession proceedings citing historical causes, tariffs and the federal government’s usurpation of the “voluntary compact” called the U.S. Constitution.
-U.S. President Buchanan begins deliberations over payment for federal properties with South Carolina representatives and is informed that garrisoning troops at Fort Sumter would be considered and act of war.
-December 8th, The South Carolina Delegation delivers a written agreement or “armistice” to U.S. President Buchanan, promising not to attack the remaining forts garrisoning U.S. troops in the sovereign state of South Carolina, with the understanding that the U.S. will not attempt to reinforce them.
-U.S. President Buchanan extended the December 10th “armistice” to all states considering secession.
-December 12th, U.S. President Buchanan’s armistice agreement that “there would be no reinforcement coastal fortifications” was now extended to all states considering secession until March 4, 1861.
-December 13th, The “Southern Manifesto” was published In Montgomery Alabama. Twenty-three House members and seven Senators from southern states make a public announcement, “a manifesto which urged secession and the organization of a Southern Confederacy.”
-December 16th, South Carolina legislature elects Francis Wilkinson Pickens Governor. In his inaugural address he cited the sectional election, northern states violations of the Constitution and that South Carolina will open her ports to the world and advocate free trade, (Without the U.S. 48% Morrill Tariffs) and that South Carolina “acceded to the Constitution alone, and will secede alone of necessity.”
-December 17th, “Convention of the People of South Carolina”, South Carolina’s Secession Convention opens, the Convention passed a unanimous resolution to secede from its voluntary compact with the union.
-December 20th, Delegates to the South Carolina Convention unanimously vote to secede by adopting 169 – 0 an “Ordinance To Dissolve the Union between the State of South Carolina and other States United with her under the Compact Entitled ‘The Constitution of the United States of America.’
-December 21st, Incoming U.S. President Lincoln sends a “confidential” letter to Democrat Francis P. Blair, Sr., Representative Elihu B. Washburn, and General Winfield Scott, regarding his plan to break US President Buchanan’s armistice and instigate war on American state’s immediately after inauguration.
-December 23rd, South Carolina’s Rep. William Porcher Miles confirms the December 10th armistice with U.S. President Buchanan and that Fort Sumter is abandoned property In Charleston Harbor, now sits unoccupied.
-December 26th, U.S. Major Robert Anderson violates U.S. President Buchanan’s December 10th armistice with South Carolina’s Representatives, and Governor, by illegally seizing Fort Sumter in Charleston Harbor, (Act of War)
-December 28th, In response to U.S. Major Andersons illegal seizure and occupation of Fort Sumter, Cadet Riflemen and the Palmetto Guard, with a detachment of City Police, were detailed to take charge of the Arsenal in the city of Charleston, and a line of patrols was established around the walls.
-December 30th, Colonial John Cunningham of the South Carolina militia was officially ordered by Governor Francis Pickens to seize control of the Charleston Arsenal.
-January 1st 1861, Political Resignations Begin, Labors expose US. Maj. Anderson’s subversion, U.S. Blockade of Charleston Harbor expected (Act of War).
-January 2nd, Gulf state Governors and local officials order State Guard Troops, Local Militias and Police to secure or seize coastal forts, armories, and powder magazines.
-January 4th, Governor A.B. Moore ordered Alabama Militia to seize three installations in the state, the arsenal at Mount Vernon, Fort Morgan and Fort Gaines, in preparation for secession.
-U.S. President Buchanan responded to Major Anderson’s breach of the “compact” or Armistice of December 10th, by justifying it as a “military necessity” to occupy Fort Sumter, and blaming possible “Mob” violence.
-Rumors that the steamer “Harriet Lane”had been hired and dispatched, with supplies and 150 reinforcements for U.S. Major Anderson at Fort Sumter. (Act of War)
-January 5th, A caucus of U.S. Senators from seven Southern states meet in Washington, D.C.. The Senators from South Carolina, Mississippi, Florida, Alabama, Georgia, Louisiana, and Texas discuss an orderly secession, independence and a “confederation of states.”
-January 7th, U.S. Congressional Committee “on the part of the boarder states” proposes a constitutional amendment to ensure chattel slavery, and the interstate slave trade, is made “permanent and irrevocable” in all states “loyal to the union”…
-January 8th, The Steamer “Star of the West” has been hired by President Buchanan to invade Charleston Harbor with 150-200 reinforcements and supplies for Fort Sumter, in violation of the December 10th Armistice. (Act of War)
-January 9th, The Steamer “Star of the West” arrives at Charleston with supplies and reinforcements for Fort Sumter and attempts to invade the Harbor but, is unable to navigate the channel. (Act of War)… South Carolina forces fire warning shots, block the channel, and the ship is ordered to retreat.
–Mississippi votes to join South Carolina in secession and independence from the Union.
-January 10th, Florida joins South Carolina and Mississippi and secedes from the federal Union, U.S. forces break the armistice with Florida’s Governor and occupy the formerly abandoned Fort Pickens. (Act of War)
-January 11th, Alabama votes for secession and independence from the federal union, discussions of a “Southern Confederacy” begin. *The first Black “Freedmen” Volunteers begin to be accepted into service to the South Carolina state militia’s.
-January 12th, Fort Sumter Deliberations begin between U. S. President Buchanan and South Carolina, and S.C. Governor Pickens sends a letter to U.S. Major Anderson at Fort Sumter. (Attempted at a peaceful resolution)
-January 13th, The South Carolina General Assembly looks upon any attempt to reinforce the troops now in possession of Fort Sumter, as an act of open and undisguised hostility on the part of the Government of the United States.
-January 15th, Louisiana Governor orders Coastal Forts to be seized, the “Star of the West” returns to New York with reinforcements and supplies after being turned away from Charleston Harbor South Carolina.
-January 16th, The “Crittenden Compromise” Bill dies in the U.S. Senate, the U.S. government continues to offer amendments to make chattel slavery “permanent and irrevocable” in all states “loyal to the union”.
-January 17th, The War Ship U.S.S. Brooklyn attempts to invade Charleston Harbor and is turned back (Act of War), more U.S. Officers resign to join their respective states militias, some Virginia counties urge secession.
-January 18th, South Carolina Governor Pickens is authorized to raise an army, and declared South Carolina ports are closed to northern shipping.
—-A U.S. federal fleet, led by the U.S.S. Macedonian with 500+ men and 36 guns, is sent under sealed (Secret) orders to break the armistice and reinforce Fort Pickens in the now Independent Republic of Florida. (Act of War)
-January 19th, The State of Georgia becomes the 5th state to vote to secede from the Union, and Former U.S. President Taylor leads a piece delegation while U.S. President Buchanan secretly develops plans to invade former states and reinforce Forts Pickens and Sumter.
-January 21st, The Honorable Jefferson Davis of Mississippi, hero of the Mexican War, former U.S. Secretary of War, resigns from the U.S. Senate.
-January 24th, U.S. Major Anderson receives word that February 9th has been established as the date by which his command would be “evacuated with honor” as per the armistice, his men travel freely, and that his command is being supplied with fresh produce and meat by Charleston merchants.
-January 26th, Louisiana joins South Carolina, Mississippi, Florida, Alabama and Georgia in voting for secession.
-January 29th, The territory of Kansas is admitted to federal union as the 34th state. The Charleston Mercury Hails Kansas for ensuring “Popular Sovereignty” as its citizens determine its domestic institutions and not the federal government.
-February 1st, The people of Texas vote to become the 7th state to secede from its voluntary compact with the federal union.
-February 4th, A Peace Commission convened in Washington D.C., while Convention Delegates from seven independent states is assembled in Montgomery Alabama to draft a provisional constitution and government for a new confederacy of states.
February 6th, U.S. President Buchanan concedes to political pressure from his cabinet and informs Peace Commissioners that he has no intention of honoring his December 10th pledge to withdraw federal forces from Fort’s Sumter and Pickens by February 9th. (Act of War)
-February 7th, U.S. President James Buchanan publicly asserts that “It is beyond the power of any president” to interfere with secession, and negotiations begin on the disposition of “public property” with seceded states.
-February 8th, A provisional confederated government and draft constitution is formally established in Montgomery Alabama by 6 independent states. (Texas Delegates in transit)
-US President Buchanan’s original armistice agreement to evacuate federal troops from all forts by February 9th, expires, he has informed former President Tyler’s Peace Commission that he now has no intention of evacuating the remaining occupation troops from the 7 newly confederated states. (Act of War)
-February 11th, Jefferson Davis is inaugurated as provisional President of the 7 Confederate States of America.
-February 13th, The U.S. Congress met in a Joint Session to count the Electoral College votes to certify the results of 1860 presidential election, the most highly contested in American history.
-February 16th, The Republic of Texas begins seizing forts and armories within its boarders after secession, and subsequently joining the C.S.A.
-February 18th, U.S. President Buchanan ordered a Naval Squadron sent to Florida with reinforcements for Fort Pickens however, is only allowed to resupply, not permitted to land troops in accordance with Buchanan’s armistice with Florida’s Governor Perry.
-February 22nd, The new Government of the Confederate States of America (CSA) has now assumed delegated authority for the coastal defenses of seven member states, with consent of the Governors.
-February 23, The Baltimore Plot”;
Rumors circulate of a plan to assassinate Abraham Lincoln, the most Unpopular President in American history, as he travels through Baltimore Maryland, on his way to Washington D.C., for his inauguration.
-February 27th, C.S. President Davis has requested commissioners to be sent to Europe to establish diplomatic relations, and names three C.S. commissioners to be sent to Washington DC to negotiate peaceful relations with the U.S. Government.
-February 28th, C.S. President Jefferson Davis becomes the first American President to use a line item veto, to specifically outlaw his nation’s participation in the international slave trade in any form, as drafted into the C.S. Constitution.
-March 2nd, With two days left in his lame duck administration, U.S. President James Buchanan is pressured to sign two landmark pieces of legislation, the “Morrill Tariffs” and the “Corwin Amendment.” Both planks in the new radical Republican platform.
-March 3rd, Abraham Lincoln sends secret orders Secretary of War, Edwin Stanton, to break the armistice and send a naval expedition from New York City, to “reinforce” U.S. Commander Slemmer at Fort Pickens Florida with four companies of U.S. troops. (Act of War)
-March 4th, Abraham Lincoln is Inaugurated as U.S. President, and he immediately orders General Winfield Scott to initiate war at Fort Pickens at Pensacola. (Act of War)
-March 11, The C.S. Constitution was unanimously ratified by seven, It outlawed participation in the international slave trade, recognized the right of any state or territories to decide the question of slavery within their own borders, and contained strict limitations on tariffs creating a low tariff zone on the North American Content. As a result, the Northeastern financial markets went into a panic!
-March 13, The U.S. Congress, Secretary of State William Seward, Confederate Peace Commissioners, American News reporters and President Lincoln’s own Cabinet are assured that troops illegally occupying Forts Pickens and Sumter are to be evacuated, and that war with the Confederate States will be avoided…
-March 15th, U.S. President Lincoln sends a letter to urge governors of U.S. states to quickly ratify the Corwin Amendment to make the institution of slavery “permanent and irrevocable” in all states a territories “loyal to the union”, without interference from the federal government.
-March 16, Arizona Territory Secedes from Lincoln’s Union.
-March 18, Gustavus V. Fox is provisionally appointed U.S. Assistant Secretary of the Navy by President Lincoln, and ordered to reconnoiter Fort Sumter and plan an invasion of Charleston Harbor, South Carolina. Against the advice of his cabinet.
-March 22nd, All U.S. Naval Commanders stationed off of Galveston TX, New Orleans LA, and Pensacola FL have all refused to execute any of Lincoln’s secret orders that could be seen as a violation of the armistice thus, initiating war.
-March 27th, C.S. General Beauregard and South Carolina’s Governor Pickens again offer U.S. Major Anderson evacuation Fort Sumter “with all honors”.
-March 29th, U.S. Merchant Ship S.S. Isabella is captured by Confederate Officers, and Lincoln’s secret plan to break the armistice is discovered on board. The French call for the “abolition” of the Morrill Tariffs as a first step in reconciliation.
-April 1st, U.S. President Lincoln severely rebuked his Secretary of State, W. H. Seward, for his continued insistence on a peaceful solution, Lincoln openly admits he will usurp the Constitution and initiate war on American states.
-April 5th, U.S. President Abraham Lincoln illegally initiates war on South Carolina, Florida, and on the Confederate States of America, without the consent of congress.
~ April 8th, 3 U.S. naval squadrons in two expeditions secretly left port, blowing gale winds, rain, and high seas. One Squadron has departed for Pensacola, two are pending departure for Charleston Harbor.
-April 10th, With the U.S. Naval Invasion Fleet in route, the C.S. Congress sends a wire to Generals Beauregard and Bragg that: “a federal [U.S.] expedition force will be landed to overcome all [C.S.] opposition”.
-April 11th, The first evacuation date of the armistice was broken on February 9th, by U.S. President Buchanan. (Act of War)
Now the second on April 10th by U.S. President Abraham Lincoln. (Act of War)
-April 12th, The U.S. Naval Fleet arrives at Charleston Harbor; Fort Sumter bombardment begins, Florida is invaded, and Fort Pickens is reinforced! War is initiated.
-April 14, 1861, Victorious Confederates occupy Fort Sumter in Charleston Harbor after the attempted federal invasion, bombardment and subsequent surrender of federal troops. Private John S. Byrd, Jr. of South Carolina’s Palmetto Guard places this flag on the fort’s wall facing Charleston.
-April 15th, Lincoln usurps the Constitution and the U.S. Congress and ordered governors to provide 75,000 troops to illegally invade C.S. States.
-Second Wave of States Secession Begins
-April 17th, U.S. President Abraham Lincoln has now formally declared war on the seven Confederate States of America without the consent of the U.S. Congress, and carrying out further invasion of Florida by reinforcing Fort Pickens.
-April 19th, U.S. President Abraham Lincoln, under a plan devised by U.S. Gen. Winfield Scott, proclaims that all Southern ports will be blockaded by the U.S. Navy (Act of War).
-April 20th, Just 3 days after Virginia’s peaceful secession from the U.S., U.S. Commodore McCauley plans and executes the demolition and evacuation of Virginia’s ports. (Act of War)
-April 21st, Pratt Street Riot, Baltimore Maryland; A clash between civilian anti-war secessionists and Union troops in Maryland’s largest city resulted in what is commonly accepted to be the first bloodshed of The War Between States.
-Maryland’s General Assembly voted to approve a resolution vehemently protesting the federal occupation of Maryland, and sent it to President Lincoln.
-April 23rd, “McClellan orders Invasion” of Virginia. (Act of War). Virginia becomes the 8th State of the Confederate States of America, and Robert E. Lee takes command of Virginia’s defense forces.
-April 25th, After illegally suspending the U.S. Constitutional “Writ of Habeas Corpus”, Abraham Lincoln orders U.S. Gen. Winfield Scott to arrest the Maryland State Legislature, and imprison them indefinitely without warrant or charges.
-April 27th, U.S. President Abraham Lincoln illegally suspended the writ of habeas corpus between Washington, D.C., and Philadelphia to give military authorities the necessary power to “silence dissenters” and “rebels”.
-April 28th, The Republic of California Moves Toward Secession and Independence
-April 29th, The Corwin Amendment goes to the state Legislatures for Ratification. U.S. President Abraham Lincoln has personally urged all governors to support this Amendment making chattel slavery “permanent and irrevocable” in all states “loyal to the Union.”
-May 3rd, U.S. President Abraham Lincoln issues Proclamation #83, which illegally established a state of war with American states, usurping the U.S. Constitution, and without the consent of the U.S. Congress.
-May 4th, The C.S. Government establishes diplomatic relations with Great Britain and Brazil. Britains Foreign Minister, Lord Lyons, attempts to negotiate a settlement to prevent U.S. President Lincoln from escalating war on American states.

Yankee Slave Traders

YANKEES MAD ABOUT SLAVERY…GOOD, they should be mad at their ancestors who brought them here, sold them while making fortunes as a result!
“Just because one voted against admitting slave states and territories into the Union did not mean they had any moral motive of concern for the liberty and well-being of the slave.
One such man was, Senator James DeWolff of Rhode Island who vehemently opposed the admission of Missouri into the Union as a slave state in 1820. DeWolff was one of the richest men in the country and had gained his wealth through the New England slave trade.
His company had made some eighty voyages to Africa until the trade became illegal for Americans in 1808. He would however continue trading slaves in a foreign market. What was the purpose of his anti-slavery position? Simply to continue New England’s policies of weakening Southern interests and not in the least a moral concern for the slave.
Another Rhode Islander John Brown (of Brown University in Providence), when criticized about his travels to Africa to buy slaves said, “There was no more crime in bringing off a cargo of slaves than in bringing off a cargo of jackasses.”

Lincoln Starts The War

 
April 13, 1861, The Road to Sumter… The U.S. invasion of C.S. Harbors and subsequent bombardment by South Carolina and C.S. Defenders has begun!
“Mr. Lincoln saw an opportunity to instigate a civil war without appearing in the character of an aggressor.” Fort Pickens in Florida is successfully reinforced, and Fort Sumter in South Carolina is evacuated.”
April 14, At 2:30am, U.S. Major Anderson agreed to C.S. General Beauregard’s terms to be “evacuated with honor” from the the fort, after withstanding a 34 hour Bombardment, from 43 guns, firing over 3,000 rounds from confederate batteries, resulting in NO U.S. federal casualties,…
—————————————————————-
~Events leading up to April 14; It is now 3 days past the armistice deadline for U.S. troops to be evacuated from harbor forts within the Confederate States of America (C.S.A.). (Act of War)
~For 4+ months Major Anderson, with 85 US Troops, has refused “evacuation with honor” from Fort Sumter, on February 9th, and now April 10th. (Act of War)
~U.S. Secretary of State Seward had informed Europeans, and the C.S.A. Peace Commissioners, that the U.S. would abide by the April 10th withdrawal date. ~U.S. President Lincoln and Captain Gustavus Fox used a 3+ month delay to secretly deploy invasion fleets, first to Ft. Pickens in Pensacola Florida, and then to Charleston Harbor in South Carolina, against the advice of his own cabinet, and without U.S. Congressional knowledge or approval. (Act of War)
~The first two warships arrived at Charleston Harbor the morning of April 12, with 300 troops “to overcome all opposition” (Act of War).
~C.S. General Beauregard gave his old friend U.S. Major Anderson 1 hour to “evacuate with honor” but Anderson refused, and the Bombardment was ordered.
~The U.S. invasion fleet could not navigate into Charleston harbor due to weather, tides, and opposition from shore batteries.
~Meanwhile that evening, Lincoln had secretly ordered a second U.S. invasion force to deploy 200 troops into Ft. Pickens at Pensacola under the cover of darkness. (Act of War).
~C.S. General Bragg Confirmed; “Re-enforcements thrown into Fort Pickens last night by small boats from the outside. The movement could not even be seen from our side . . .”” (Act of War)
The next day, after U.S. Major Robert Anderson agreed to terms to be “evacuated with honor” from Fort Sumter, U.S Troops we’re evacuated, and the Palmetto Guard Flag was placed on the wall facing the city by Private John S. Byrd. Finally the First Nation Flag of the C.S.A. was raised over Ft. Sumter. The national flag representing the first seven states, one territory, and the Indian Nations of the C.S.A..
—————————————————————-
Providence Rhode Island Daily Post,
Published April 13, 1861.
“Mr. Lincoln saw an opportunity to inaugurate civil war without appearing in the character of an aggressor.” […] “We are to have civil war, if at all, because Abraham Lincoln loves a [Republican] party better than he loves his country…. [He] clings to his party creed, and allows the nation to drift into the whirlpool of destruction.” ~
—————————————————————
Stephen Douglas, Senator from Illinois stated:
“We certainly cannot justify the holding of forts there, much less the recapturing of those which have been taken, unless we intend to reduce those States themselves into subjection. I take it for granted, no man will deny the proposition that whoever permanently holds Charleston and South Carolina is entitled to Fort Sumter…. Whoever holds the States in whose limits those forts are placed, is entitled to the forts themselves, unless there is something peculiar in the location of the same particular fort that makes it important to the general defense of the whole country, its commerce and interests, as in the case of Forts Taylor and Jefferson at Key West and Dry Tortugas. But Fort Sumter and other forts, in Charleston harbor; Fort Pulaski on the Savannah River; Fort Morgan and other forts in Alabama, were intended to guard the entrance to a particular harbor for local defense.(5) Such being the case, the occupation of Fort Sumter by U.S. troops was technically an act of invasion and the Confederate forces in Charleston were wholly justified in firing upon them when it became evident that Lincoln intended to use military force against the State.”
————————————————————-
Representative Benjamin Williams, of Lowell, Massachusetts, stated in a speech to the U.S. Congress:
“The South was invaded and a war of subjugation was begun by the Federal government against the seceding States in amazing disregard of the foundation principle of its existence-and the South accepts the contest forced upon her with a courage characteristic of this proud-spirited people. The North had no Constitutional right to hold Fort Sumter in case the States seceded and to hold it meant war.”
—————————————————————-
NEW YORK TIMES
APRIL 13, 1861
FORT SUMTER–1861–1865.; Historical Sketch of the Bombardment and Surrender of Fort Sumter in April, 1861. THE EFFECT IN CHARLESTON DEMAND FOR THE SURRENDER RETURN FIRE THE SECOND DAY SURRENDER. THE THIRD DAY, Correspondent; “Jasper”.
“Assuming to regard the temporary absence of the flag as an indication of a desire to…
[C.S.] Mr. WIGFALL, of Texas, made his appearance with his handkerchief waving, and desired admission. It was granted, but as the national colors still waved defiance, the rebel batteries continued their fire. After some consultation, Mr. WIGFALL displayed his improvised flag-of-truce, and having heard Maj. ANDERSON’s ultimatum, departed to report to [C.S.] Gen. BEAUREGARD. The firing ceased, and as the smoke rolled off the sickening devastation was apparent. While Mr. WIGFALL was yet on his way to the shore, a second deputation, consisting of [C.S.] Maj. LEE, PORCHER MILES, ex-Senator CHESNUT and ROGER A. PRYOR, appeared, and subsequently a third, Maj. JONES, Chief of Staff to Gen. BEAUREGARD, made their appearance, and the terms of surrender were agreed upon.
Sunday, the 14th of April, witnessed the occupation of the rebels, the withdrawal of Maj. ANDERSON and his forces, but not the disgrace of the old flag. The steamer Isabel was provided by the Confederates for the transportation of the entire force North, with all their company and personal property. At noon all hands were assembled on the parade-ground, about which were strewn the wreck and ruin of the fort. The battle-flag under which the gallant garrison had fought, in whose defence they had endured so much, and for whose honor they had periled life and limb, was again brought out, and, in perfect silence, with befitting ceremony and reverence, was raised to the very top of the staff. When there it was saluted with fifty guns, while every head uncovered and every heart swelled with patriotic emotion. A [U.S.] private — DAVID HOUGH — was killed by the accidental discharge of some fixed ammunition, and after he had been buried, with military honors, the flag was lowered, and Maj. ANDERSON and his command, with the colors flying from the mast-head of the Isabel, steamed homeward to meet a glorious welcome from a people roused by the echo of BEAUREGARD’s guns to the dreadful struggle which was to mark the ensuing years.
To-day Maj. (now Gen.) ANDERSON will rates over the ruins of Sumter the flag he so unwillingly hauled down.”
————————————————————-
Sources:
Current, Lincoln and the First Shot, pp. 154-55, 170-73;
OR, 251-52; Lincoln, Collected Works, ed. Basler, 4: 324.
OR, pp. 289, 291, 456-58; McWhiney, “Confederacy’s First Shot,” p. 12.
OR, pp. 459-60; ORN, p. 118; Nicolay and Hay, Lincoln, 4: 12-13; Welles, Diary of Gideon Welles, ed. Morse, 1: 31.
OR, pp. 376, 462-63; Nicolay and Hay, Lincoln, 4: 11-13.
* Long, E.B. with Long, Barbara, The Civil War Day by Day (New York: Da Capo Press, Inc., 1971), p. 50, 52
1. Horton, History of the Great Civil War, pages 71-72.
2. The Statutes at Large of South Carolina (Columbia, South Carolina: A.S. Johnston, 1836), Volume V, page 501.
3. Congressional Globe (Thirty-Sixth Congress, Second Session), 13 December 1860, page 86.
4. Davis, Rise and Fall of the Confederate Government, Volume I, page 211.
5. Stephen Douglas, speech in the Senate on 15 March 1861; Congressional Globe (Thirty-Sixth Congress, Second Session), page 1459.
6. Robert Selph Henry, The Story of the Confederacy (New York: Garden City Publishing Company, 1931), pages 19, 33.
7. Robert Toombs, quoted by Burton J. Hendrick, Statesmen of the Lost Cause: Jefferson Davis and His Cabinet (New York: The Literary Guild of America, Inc., 1939), page 106.
8. Chamber’s Journal, 5 December 1863; quoted by Adams, In the Course of Human Events, page 17.
9. Lincoln, quoted by Orville H. Browning, Diary (Springfield, Illinois: Illinois State Historical Library, 1933; edited by Theodore C. Pease and James G. Randall), entry for 3 July 1861.
10. Nicolay and Hay, Abraham Lincoln: Complete Works, Volume IV, page 44.
11. Pittsburgh (Pennsylvania) Daily Gazette, 18 April 1861.
12. Joseph Lane, Congressional Globe (Thirty-Sixth Congress, Second Session), page 1347.
13. Lincoln, in Richardson, Messages and Papers of the Presidents, Volume VII, page 3223.
14. New York Express, 15 April 1861; quoted by Rutherford, Truths of History, page 9.
15. Horton, History of the Great Civil War, pages 113-114.
—————————————————————
Events leading up to April 13, 1861:
-80+ years of sectional tensions between northeastern and southeastern states over tariffs, states rights/popular sovereignty, federal power over new territories and most recently, the practice of chattel slavery.
-1857 – Massive Financial Collapse And panic hits Northeastern banks triggered by the sinking sinking of the S.S. Central America carrying 30,000 pounds of gold destined for northern banks.
-A new “Republican” political party is formed with a platform of federal control of new territories, diminishing popular sovereignty, and enforcing new tariffs “by force”, which are all usurpations of the U.S. Constitution.
-The increasing federal debt has lead to a proposed drastic increase in Tariffs that disproportionately effect agricultural southern states as the 48% Morrill Tariffs.
-Radical Republican Leader Thaddeus Stevens, sponsor of the Morrill Tariff, stated: “the Tariff would impoverish the southern and western states, but that was essential for advancing national greatness and the prosperity of [northern] industrial workers.”
-Southeastern states have minority representation in the U.S. Congress due to the 3/5ths rule, which does not allow negro persons to be fully counted for representation.
-Southeastern “Cotton states” protest tariffs, and the fact that these agricultural state are already paying ~75% to 85% of the federal budget with little to none returned in support for infrastructure.
-1859 – John Brown and 18 accomplices began their illegal invasion of Virginia, and murder spree at Harper’s Ferry Virginia, financed by northeastern “abolitionists”.
-November 1860, Abraham Lincoln is selected as U.S. President with a minority of the popular vote and was not even on the ballot in 10 states, with a pledge to institute the new party’s platform, by force if necessary.
-The seven “cotton states” that are most impacted by the new 48% Morrill Tariffs begin secession proceedings citing historical causes, tariffs and the federal government’s usurpation of the “voluntary compact” called the U.S. Constitution.
-U.S. President Buchanan begins deliberations over payment for federal properties with South Carolina representatives and is informed that garrisoning troops at Fort Sumter would be considered and act of war.
-December 8th, The South Carolina Delegation delivers a written agreement or “armistice” to U.S. President Buchanan, promising not to attack the remaining forts garrisoning U.S. troops in the sovereign state of South Carolina, with the understanding that the U.S. will not attempt to reinforce them.
-U.S. President Buchanan extended the December 10th “armistice” to all states considering secession.
-December 12th, U.S. President Buchanan’s armistice agreement that “there would be no reinforcement coastal fortifications” was now extended to all states considering secession until March 4, 1861.
-December 13th, The “Southern Manifesto” was published In Montgomery Alabama. Twenty-three House members and seven Senators from southern states make a public announcement, “a manifesto which urged secession and the organization of a Southern Confederacy.”
-December 16th, South Carolina legislature elects Francis Wilkinson Pickens Governor. In his inaugural address he cited the sectional election, northern states violations of the Constitution and that South Carolina will open her ports to the world and advocate free trade, (Without the U.S. 48% Morrill Tariffs) and that South Carolina “acceded to the Constitution alone, and will secede alone of necessity.”
-December 17th, “Convention of the People of South Carolina”, South Carolina’s Secession Convention opens, the Convention passed a unanimous resolution to secede from its voluntary compact with the union.
-December 20th, Delegates to the South Carolina Convention unanimously vote to secede by adopting 169 – 0 an “Ordinance To Dissolve the Union between the State of South Carolina and other States United with her under the Compact Entitled ‘The Constitution of the United States of America.’
-December 21st, Incoming U.S. President Lincoln sends a “confidential” letter to Democrat Francis P. Blair, Sr., Representative Elihu B. Washburn, and General Winfield Scott, regarding his plan to break US President Buchanan’s armistice and instigate war on American state’s immediately after inauguration.
-December 23rd, South Carolina’s Rep. William Porcher Miles confirms the December 10th armistice with U.S. President Buchanan and that Fort Sumter is abandoned property In Charleston Harbor, now sits unoccupied.
-December 26th, U.S. Major Robert Anderson violates U.S. President Buchanan’s December 10th armistice with South Carolina’s Representatives, and Governor, by illegally seizing Fort Sumter in Charleston Harbor, (Act of War)
-December 28th, In response to U.S. Major Andersons illegal seizure and occupation of Fort Sumter, Cadet Riflemen and the Palmetto Guard, with a detachment of City Police, were detailed to take charge of the Arsenal in the city of Charleston, and a line of patrols was established around the walls.
-December 30th, Colonial John Cunningham of the South Carolina militia was officially ordered by Governor Francis Pickens to seize control of the Charleston Arsenal.
-January 1st 1861, Political Resignations Begin, Labors expose US. Maj. Anderson’s subversion, U.S. Blockade of Charleston Harbor expected (Act of War).
-January 2nd, Gulf state Governors and local officials order State Guard Troops, Local Militias and Police to secure or seize coastal forts, armories, and powder magazines.
-January 4th, Governor A.B. Moore ordered Alabama Militia to seize three installations in the state, the arsenal at Mount Vernon, Fort Morgan and Fort Gaines, in preparation for secession.
-U.S. President Buchanan responded to Major Anderson’s breach of the “compact” or Armistice of December 10th, by justifying it as a “military necessity” to occupy Fort Sumter, and blaming possible “Mob” violence.
-Rumors that the steamer “Harriet Lane”had been hired and dispatched, with supplies and 150 reinforcements for U.S. Major Anderson at Fort Sumter. (Act of War)
-January 5th, A caucus of U.S. Senators from seven Southern states meet in Washington, D.C.. The Senators from South Carolina, Mississippi, Florida, Alabama, Georgia, Louisiana, and Texas discuss an orderly secession, independence and a “confederation of states.”
-January 7th, U.S. Congressional Committee “on the part of the boarder states” proposes a constitutional amendment to ensure chattel slavery, and the interstate slave trade, is made “permanent and irrevocable” in all states “loyal to the union”…
-January 8th, The Steamer “Star of the West” has been hired by President Buchanan to invade Charleston Harbor with 150-200 reinforcements and supplies for Fort Sumter, in violation of the December 10th Armistice. (Act of War)
-January 9th, The Steamer “Star of the West” arrives at Charleston with supplies and reinforcements for Fort Sumter and attempts to invade the Harbor but, is unable to navigate the channel. (Act of War)… South Carolina forces fire warning shots, block the channel, and the ship is ordered to retreat.
–Mississippi votes to join South Carolina in secession and independence from the Union.
-January 10th, Florida joins South Carolina and Mississippi and secedes from the federal Union, U.S. forces break the armistice with Florida’s Governor and occupy the formerly abandoned Fort Pickens. (Act of War)
-January 11th, Alabama votes for secession and independence from the federal union, discussions of a “Southern Confederacy” begin. *The first Black “Freedmen” Volunteers begin to be accepted into service to the South Carolina state militia’s.
-January 12th, Fort Sumter Deliberations begin between U. S. President Buchanan and South Carolina, and S.C. Governor Pickens sends a letter to U.S. Major Anderson at Fort Sumter. (Attempted at a peaceful resolution)
-January 13th, The South Carolina General Assembly looks upon any attempt to reinforce the troops now in possession of Fort Sumter, as an act of open and undisguised hostility on the part of the Government of the United States.
-January 15th, Louisiana Governor orders Coastal Forts to be seized, the “Star of the West” returns to New York with reinforcements and supplies after being turned away from Charleston Harbor South Carolina.
-January 16th, The “Crittenden Compromise” Bill dies in the U.S. Senate, the U.S. government continues to offer amendments to make chattel slavery “permanent and irrevocable” in all states “loyal to the union”.
-January 17th, The War Ship U.S.S. Brooklyn attempts to invade Charleston Harbor and is turned back (Act of War), more U.S. Officers resign to join their respective states militias, some Virginia counties urge secession.
-January 18th, South Carolina Governor Pickens is authorized to raise an army, and declared South Carolina ports are closed to northern shipping.
—-A U.S. federal fleet, led by the U.S.S. Macedonian with 500+ men and 36 guns, is sent under sealed (Secret) orders to break the armistice and reinforce Fort Pickens in the now Independent Republic of Florida. (Act of War)
-January 19th, The State of Georgia becomes the 5th state to vote to secede from the Union, and Former U.S. President Taylor leads a piece delegation while U.S. President Buchanan secretly develops plans to invade former states and reinforce Forts Pickens and Sumter.
-January 21st, The Honorable Jefferson Davis of Mississippi, hero of the Mexican War, former U.S. Secretary of War, resigns from the U.S. Senate.
-January 24th, U.S. Major Anderson receives word that February 9th has been established as the date by which his command would be “evacuated with honor” as per the armistice, his men travel freely, and that his command is being supplied with fresh produce and meat by Charleston merchants.
-January 26th, Louisiana joins South Carolina, Mississippi, Florida, Alabama and Georgia in voting for secession.
-January 29th, The territory of Kansas is admitted to federal union as the 34th state. The Charleston Mercury Hails Kansas for ensuring “Popular Sovereignty” as its citizens determine its domestic institutions and not the federal government.
-February 1st, The people of Texas vote to become the 7th state to secede from its voluntary compact with the federal union.
-February 4th, A Peace Commission convened in Washington D.C., while Convention Delegates from seven independent states is assembled in Montgomery Alabama to draft a provisional constitution and government for a new confederacy of states.
February 6th, U.S. President Buchanan concedes to political pressure from his cabinet and informs Peace Commissioners that he has no intention of honoring his December 10th pledge to withdraw federal forces from Fort’s Sumter and Pickens by February 9th. (Act of War)
-February 7th, U.S. President James Buchanan publicly asserts that “It is beyond the power of any president” to interfere with secession, and negotiations begin on the disposition of “public property” with seceded states.
-February 8th, A provisional confederated government and draft constitution is formally established in Montgomery Alabama by 6 independent states. (Texas Delegates in transit)
-US President Buchanan’s original armistice agreement to evacuate federal troops from all forts by February 9th, expires, he has informed former President Tyler’s Peace Commission that he now has no intention of evacuating the remaining occupation troops from the 7 newly confederated states. (Act of War)
-February 11th, Jefferson Davis is inaugurated as provisional President of the 7 Confederate States of America.
-February 13th, The U.S. Congress met in a Joint Session to count the Electoral College votes to certify the results of 1860 presidential election, the most highly contested in American history.
-February 16th, The Republic of Texas begins seizing forts and armories within its boarders after secession, and subsequently joining the C.S.A.
-February 18th, U.S. President Buchanan ordered a Naval Squadron sent to Florida with reinforcements for Fort Pickens however, is only allowed to resupply, not permitted to land troops in accordance with Buchanan’s armistice with Florida’s Governor Perry.
-February 22nd, The new Government of the Confederate States of America (CSA) has now assumed delegated authority for the coastal defenses of seven member states, with consent of the Governors.
-February 23, The Baltimore Plot”;
Rumors circulate of a plan to assassinate Abraham Lincoln, the most Unpopular President in American history, as he travels through Baltimore Maryland, on his way to Washington D.C., for his inauguration.
-February 27th, C.S. President Davis has requested commissioners to be sent to Europe to establish diplomatic relations, and names three C.S. commissioners to be sent to Washington DC to negotiate peaceful relations with the U.S. Government.
-February 28th, C.S. President Jefferson Davis becomes the first American President to use a line item veto, to specifically outlaw his nation’s participation in the international slave trade in any form, as drafted into the C.S. Constitution.
-March 2nd, With two days left in his lame duck administration, U.S. President James Buchanan is pressured to sign two landmark pieces of legislation, the “Morrill Tariffs” and the “Corwin Amendment.” Both planks in the new radical Republican platform.
-March 3rd, Abraham Lincoln sends secret orders Secretary of War, Edwin Stanton, to break the armistice and send a naval expedition from New York City, to “reinforce” U.S. Commander Slemmer at Fort Pickens Florida with four companies of U.S. troops. (Act of War)
-March 4th, Abraham Lincoln is Inaugurated as U.S. President, and he immediately orders General Winfield Scott to initiate war at Fort Pickens at Pensacola. (Act of War)
-March 11, The C.S. Constitution was unanimously ratified by seven, It outlawed participation in the international slave trade, recognized the right of any state or territories to decide the question of slavery within their own borders, and contained strict limitations on tariffs creating a low tariff zone on the North American Content. As a result, the Northeastern financial markets went into a panic!
-March 13, The U.S. Congress, Secretary of State William Seward, Confederate Peace Commissioners, American News reporters and President Lincoln’s own Cabinet are assured that troops illegally occupying Forts Pickens and Sumter are to be evacuated, and that war with the Confederate States will be avoided…
-March 15th, U.S. President Lincoln sends a letter to urge governors of U.S. states to quickly ratify the Corwin Amendment to make the institution of slavery “permanent and irrevocable” in all states a territories “loyal to the union”, without interference from the federal government.
-March 16, Arizona Territory Secedes from Lincoln’s Union.
-March 18, Gustavus V. Fox is provisionally appointed U.S. Assistant Secretary of the Navy by President Lincoln, and ordered to reconnoiter Fort Sumter and plan an invasion of Charleston Harbor, South Carolina. Against the advice of his cabinet.
-March 22nd, All U.S. Naval Commanders stationed off of Galveston TX, New Orleans LA, and Pensacola FL have all refused to execute any of Lincoln’s secret orders that could be seen as a violation of the armistice thus, initiating war.
-March 27th, C.S. General Beauregard and South Carolina’s Governor Pickens again offer U.S. Major Anderson evacuation Fort Sumter “with all honors”.
-March 29th, U.S. Merchant Ship S.S. Isabella is captured by Confederate Officers, and Lincoln’s secret plan to break the armistice is discovered on board. The French call for the “abolition” of the Morrill Tariffs as a first step in reconciliation.
-April 1st, U.S. President Lincoln severely rebuked his Secretary of State, W. H. Seward, for his continued insistence on a peaceful solution, Lincoln openly admits he will usurp the Constitution and initiate war on American states.
-April 5th, U.S. President Abraham Lincoln illegally initiates war on South Carolina, Florida, and on the Confederate States of America, without the consent of congress.
~ April 8th, 3 U.S. naval squadrons in two expeditions secretly left port, blowing gale winds, rain, and high seas. One Squadron has departed for Pensacola, two are pending departure for Charleston Harbor.
-April 10th, With the U.S. Naval Invasion Fleet in route, the C.S. Congress sends a wire to Generals Beauregard and Bragg that: “a federal [U.S.] expedition force will be landed to overcome all [C.S.] opposition”.
-April 11th, The first evacuation date of the armistice was broken on February 9th, by U.S. President Buchanan. (Act of War)
Now the second on April 10th by U.S. President Abraham Lincoln. (Act of War)
-April 12th, The U.S. Naval Fleet arrives at Charleston Harbor; Fort Sumter bombardment begins, Florida is invaded, and Fort Pickens is reinforced! War is initiated.
Note: April 14, 1861, victorious Confederates occupy Fort Sumter in Charleston Harbor after driving off Union troops. Private John S. Byrd, Jr. of South Carolina’s Palmetto Guard places this flag on the fort’s wall facing Charleston.

The Truth

May be an image of 1 person
In answer to a captured Yankee Colonel’s question, “Who fired the first shot?” An unidentified Confederate private responds in May 1862 after Stonewall Jackson’s liberation of Winchester VA.
“John Brown at Harper’s Ferry, sir, he fired the first gun and Mr. Lincoln, in attempting to reinforce Sumter, fired the second gun. And the Confederates have acted on the defensive all of the time. We did not invade your country, but you invaded ours, you go home and attend to your own business and leave us to ours and the war will close at once.”

Woodrow Wilson quote

It was necessary to put the South at a moral disadvantage by transforming the contest from a war waged against states fighting for their indepdence into a war waged against states fighting for the maintenance and extension of slavery…and the world, it might be hoped, would see it as a moral war, not a political; and the sympathy of nations would begin to run for the North, not for the South.

From the Land of Lincoln

This video shows Professor Kate Masur delivering a lecture to the 2023 Lincoln Forum in Gettysburg, PA on the Antebellum Black Laws in Illinois.

The video’s description reads, “Historian Kate Masur talked about the fight for African American freedom and equality, from the Revolutionary War to Reconstruction, with a focus on Black Laws in antebellum Illinois. This event was part the 2023 Lincoln Forum held in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania.”

https://www.c-span.org/video/?531806-3/black-laws-antebellum-illinois

War Crimes: March 3, 1865

Jim Harrleson

War Crimes: March 3, 1865, Confederate Prisoners put into Camps infected with Small-pox…

“But even a greater inhumanity than any we have mentioned, was perpetrated upon our prisoners at Camp Douglas and Camp Chase. It is proved by the testimony of Thomas P. Holloway, John P. Fennell, H. H. Barlow, H. C. Barton, C. D. Bracken and J. S. Barlow, that our prisoners in large numbers were put into “condemned camps,” where small-pox was prevailing, and speedily contracted this loathsome disease, and that as many as 40 new cases often appeared daily among them. Even the Federal officers who guarded them to the camp, protested against this unnatural atrocity; yet it was done. The men who contracted the disease were removed to a hospital about a mile off, but the plague was already introduced, and continued to prevail. For a period of more than twelve months, the disease was constantly in the camp; yet our prisoners during all this time were continually brought to it, and subjected to certain infection. Neither do we find evidences of amendment on the part of our enemies, notwithstanding the boasts of the “sanitary commission.” At Nashville, prisoners recently captured from Gen. Hood’s army, even when sick and wounded, have been cruelly deprived of all nourishment suited to their condition; and other prisoners from the same army have been carried into the infected Camps Douglas and Chase.

“Many of the soldiers of Gen. Hood’s army were frost-bitten by being kept day and night in an exposed condition before they were put into Camp Douglas. Their sufferings are truthfully depicted in the evidence. At Alton and Camp Morton the same inhuman practice of putting our prisoners into camps infected by small-pox, prevailed. It was equivalent to murdering many of them by the torture of a contagious disease. The insufficient rations at Camp Morton forced our men to appease their hunger by pounding up and boiling bones, picking up scraps of meat and cabbage from the hospital slop tubs, and even eating rats and dogs. The depositions of William Ayres and J. Chambers Brent prove these privations.”

Source: Report of the Joint Select Committee Appointed to Investigate the Condition and Treatment of Prisoners of War: Confederate States of America. Congress. Joint Select Committee to Investigate the Condition and Treatment of Prisoners of War.

Link to free e-book: http://docsouth.unc.edu/imls/report/report.html

The Road to Sumter +40

February 27, 1861, The Road to Sumter +40:
“Being animated by an earnest desire to unite and bind together our respective countries by friendly ties, I have appointed M. J. Crawford, one of our most settled and trustworthy citizens, as special commissioner of the Confederate States of America to the Government of the United States”
~C.S. President Jefferson Davis
—————————————————————-
-Forts Sumter and Pickens now remain illegally occupied by federal troops 18 days past the evacuation deadline agreed upon by U.S. President Buchanan.
-Former President Tyler’s US Peace Convention Offers Compromise, after almost three weeks of deliberation, the US National Peace Convention adopted and sent to Congress six proposed constitutional amendments to restore sectional harmony. Its key territorial provision, to extend the Missouri Compromise line west to the Pacific Ocean, and providing for “permanent and irrevocable slavery” south of the line if seceded C.S. states return to the U.S.. The measure failed to pass without support from the seven now independent states of the C.S…
-C.S. President Davis has requested commissioners to be sent to Europe to establish diplomatic relations, and names three C.S. commissioners to be sent to Washington DC to negotiate peaceful relations with the U.S. Government.
—————————————————————
February 27, 1861, MONTGOMERY
[To] The President of the United States:
Being animated by an earnest desire to unite and bind together our respective countries by friendly ties, I have appointed M. J. Crawford, one of our most settled and trustworthy citizens, as special commissioner of the Confederate States of America to the Government of the United States; and I have now the honor to introduce him to you, and to ask for him a reception and treatment corresponding to his station and to the purpose for which he is sent. Those purposes he will more particularly explain to you. Hoping that through his agency. &c. [sic.]
JEFFERSON F. DAVIS
For the purpose of establishing friendly relations between the Confederate States and the United States, and reposing special trust, &c., Martin J. Crawford, John Forsyth, and A. B. Roman are appointed special commissioners of the Confederate States to the United States. I have invested them with full and all manner of power and authority for and in the name of the Confederate States to meet and confer with any person or persons duly authorized by the Government of the United States being furnished with like powers and authority, and with them to agree, treat, consult, and negotiate of and concerning all matters and subjects interesting to both nations, and to conclude and sign a treaty or treaties, convention or conventions, touching the premises, transmitting the same to the President of the Confederate States for his final ratification by and with the consent of the Congress of the Confederate States.
Given under my hand at the city of Montgomery this 27th day of February, A.D. 1861, and of the Independence of the Confederate States the eighty-fifth.
JEFFERSON F. DAVIS
ROBERT TOOMBS, Secretary of State.
———————————————————-
Sources: Nicolay and Hay, Lincoln, 3: 232-33; Gunderson, Old Gentlemen’s Convention, pp. 85-95;
Long, Civil War, p. 42-44; Rhodes, History, 3: 305-8.
Nicolay and Hay, Lincoln, 3: 396;
Long, Civil War, p. 42; Rhodes, History, 3: 295.
————————————————————-
Events leading up to February 27, 1861:
-80+ years of sectional tensions between northeastern and southeastern states over tariffs, states rights/popular sovereignty, federal power over new territories and most recently, the practice of chattel slavery.
-1857 – Massive Financial Collapse And panic hits Northeastern banks triggered by the sinking sinking of the S.S. Central America carrying 30,000 pounds of gold destined for northern banks.
-A new “Republican” political party is formed with a platform of federal control of new territories, diminishing popular sovereignty, and enforcing new tariffs “by force”, which are all usurpations of the U.S. Constitution.
-The increasing federal debt has lead to a proposed drastic increase in Tariffs that disproportionately effect agricultural southern states as the 48% Morrill Tariffs.
-Radical Republican Leader Thaddeus Stevens, sponsor of the Morrill Tariff, stated: “the Tariff would impoverish the southern and western states, but that was essential for advancing national greatness and the prosperity of [northern] industrial workers.”
-Southeastern states have minority representation in the U.S. Congress due to the 3/5ths rule, which does not allow negro persons to be fully counted for representation.
-Southeastern “Cotton states” protest tariffs, and the fact that these agricultural state are already paying ~75% to 85% of the federal budget with little to none returned in support for infrastructure.
-1859 – John Brown and 18 accomplices began their illegal invasion of Virginia, and murder spree at Harper’s Ferry Virginia, financed by northeastern “abolitionists”.
-November 1860, Abraham Lincoln is selected as U.S. President with a minority of the popular vote and was not even on the ballot in 10 states, with a pledge to institute the new party’s platform, by force if necessary.
-The seven “cotton states” that are most impacted by the new 48% Morrill Tariffs begin secession proceedings citing historical causes, tariffs and the federal government’s usurpation of the “voluntary compact” called the U.S. Constitution.
-U.S. President Buchanan begins deliberations over payment for federal properties with South Carolina representatives and is informed that garrisoning troops at Fort Sumter would be considered and act of war.
-December 8th, The South Carolina Delegation delivers a written agreement or “armistice” to U.S. President Buchanan, promising not to attack the remaining forts garrisoning U.S. troops in the sovereign state of South Carolina, with the understanding that the U.S. will not attempt to reinforce them.
-U.S. President Buchanan extended the December 10th “armistice” to all states considering secession.
-December 12th, U.S. President Buchanan’s armistice agreement that “there would be no reinforcement coastal fortifications” was now extended to all states considering secession until March 4, 1861.
-December 13th, The “Southern Manifesto” was published In Montgomery Alabama. Twenty-three House members and seven Senators from southern states make a public announcement, “a manifesto which urged secession and the organization of a Southern Confederacy.”
-December 16th, South Carolina legislature elects Francis Wilkinson Pickens Governor. In his inaugural address he cited the sectional election, northern states violations of the Constitution and that South Carolina will open her ports to the world and advocate free trade, (Without the U.S. 48% Morrill Tariffs) and that South Carolina “acceded to the Constitution alone, and will secede alone of necessity.”
-December 17th, “Convention of the People of South Carolina”, South Carolina’s Secession Convention opens, the Convention passed a unanimous resolution to secede from its voluntary compact with the union.
-December 20th, Delegates to the South Carolina Convention unanimously vote to secede by adopting 169 – 0 an “Ordinance To Dissolve the Union between the State of South Carolina and other States United with her under the Compact Entitled ‘The Constitution of the United States of America.’
-December 21st, Incoming U.S. President Lincoln sends a “confidential” letter to Democrat Francis P. Blair, Sr., Representative Elihu B. Washburn, and General Winfield Scott, regarding his plan to break US President Buchanan’s armistice and instigate war on American state’s immediately after inauguration.
-December 23rd, South Carolina’s Rep. William Porcher Miles confirms the December 10th armistice with U.S. President Buchanan and that Fort Sumter is abandoned property In Charleston Harbor, now sits unoccupied.
-December 26th, U.S. Major Robert Anderson violates U.S. President Buchanan’s December 10th armistice with South Carolina’s Representatives, and Governor, by illegally seizing Fort Sumter in Charleston Harbor, (Act of War)
-December 28th, In response to U.S. Major Andersons illegal seizure and occupation of Fort Sumter, Cadet Riflemen and the Palmetto Guard, with a detachment of City Police, were detailed to take charge of the Arsenal in the city of Charleston, and a line of patrols was established around the walls.
-December 30th, Colonial John Cunningham of the South Carolina militia was officially ordered by Governor Francis Pickens to seize control of the Charleston Arsenal.
-January 1st 1861, Political Resignations Begin, Labors expose US. Maj. Anderson’s subversion, U.S. Blockade of Charleston Harbor expected (Act of War).
-January 2nd, Gulf state Governors and local officials order State Guard Troops, Local Militias and Police to secure or seize coastal forts, armories, and powder magazines.
-January 4th, Governor A.B. Moore ordered Alabama Militia to seize three installations in the state, the arsenal at Mount Vernon, Fort Morgan and Fort Gaines, in preparation for secession.
-U.S. President Buchanan responded to Major Anderson’s breach of the “compact” or Armistice of December 10th, by justifying it as a “military necessity” to occupy Fort Sumter, and blaming possible “Mob” violence.
-Rumors that the steamer “Harriet Lane”had been hired and dispatched, with supplies and 150 reinforcements for U.S. Major Anderson at Fort Sumter. (Act of War)
-January 5th, A caucus of U.S. Senators from seven Southern states meet in Washington, D.C.. The Senators from South Carolina, Mississippi, Florida, Alabama, Georgia, Louisiana, and Texas discuss an orderly secession, independence and a “confederation of states.”
-January 7th, U.S. Congressional Committee “on the part of the boarder states” proposes a constitutional amendment to ensure chattel slavery, and the interstate slave trade, is made “permanent and irrevocable” in all states “loyal to the union”…
-January 8th, The Steamer “Star of the West” has been hired by President Buchanan to invade Charleston Harbor with 150-200 reinforcements and supplies for Fort Sumter, in violation of the December 10th Armistice. (Act of War)
-January 9th, The Steamer “Star of the West” arrives at Charleston with supplies and reinforcements for Fort Sumter and attempts to invade the Harbor but, is unable to navigate the channel. (Act of War)… South Carolina forces fire warning shots, block the channel, and the ship is ordered to retreat.
–Mississippi votes to join South Carolina in secession and independence from the Union.
-January 10th, Florida joins South Carolina and Mississippi and secedes from the federal Union, U.S. forces break the armistice with Florida’s Governor and occupy the formerly abandoned Fort Pickens. (Act of War)
-January 11th, Alabama votes for secession and independence from the federal union, discussions of a “Southern Confederacy” begin. *The first Black “Freedmen” Volunteers begin to be accepted into service to the South Carolina state militia’s.
-January 12th, Fort Sumter Deliberations begin between U. S. President Buchanan and South Carolina, and S.C. Governor Pickens sends a letter to U.S. Major Anderson at Fort Sumter. (Attempted at a peaceful resolution)
-January 13th, The South Carolina General Assembly looks upon any attempt to reinforce the troops now in possession of Fort Sumter, as an act of open and undisguised hostility on the part of the Government of the United States.
-January 15th, Louisiana Governor orders Coastal Forts to be seized, the “Star of the West” returns to New York with reinforcements and supplies after being turned away from Charleston Harbor South Carolina.
-January 16th, The “Crittenden Compromise” Bill dies in the U.S. Senate, the U.S. government continues to offer amendments to make chattel slavery “permanent and irrevocable” in all states “loyal to the union”.
-January 17th, The War Ship U.S.S. Brooklyn attempts to invade Charleston Harbor and is turned back (Act of War), more U.S. Officers resign to join their respective states militias, some Virginia counties urge secession.
-January 18th, South Carolina Governor Pickens is authorized to raise an army, and declared South Carolina ports are closed to northern shipping.
—-A U.S. federal fleet, led by the U.S.S. Macedonian with 500+ men and 36 guns, is sent under sealed (Secret) orders to break the armistice and reinforce Fort Pickens in the now Independent Republic of Florida. (Act of War)
-January 19th, The State of Georgia becomes the 5th state to vote to secede from the Union, and Former U.S. President Taylor leads a piece delegation while U.S. President Buchanan secretly develops plans to invade former states and reinforce Forts Pickens and Sumter.
-January 21st, The Honorable Jefferson Davis of Mississippi, hero of the Mexican War, former U.S. Secretary of War, resigns from the U.S. Senate.
-January 24th, U.S. Major Anderson receives word that February 9th has been established as the date by which his command would be “evacuated with honor” as per the armistice, his men travel freely, and that his command is being supplied with fresh produce and meat by Charleston merchants.
-January 26th, Louisiana joins South Carolina, Mississippi, Florida, Alabama and Georgia in voting for secession.
-January 29th, The territory of Kansas is admitted to federal union as the 34th state. The Charleston Mercury Hails Kansas for ensuring “Popular Sovereignty” as its citizens determine its domestic institutions and not the federal government.
-February 1st, The people of Texas vote to become the 7th state to secede from its voluntary compact with the federal union.
-February 4th, A Peace Commission convened in Washington D.C., while Convention Delegates from seven independent states is assembled in Montgomery Alabama to draft a provisional constitution and government for a new confederacy of states.
February 6th, U.S. President Buchanan concedes to political pressure from his cabinet and informs Peace Commissioners that he has no intention of honoring his December 10th pledge to withdraw federal forces from Fort’s Sumter and Pickens by February 9th. (Act of War)
-February 7th, U.S. President James Buchanan publicly asserts that “It is beyond the power of any president” to interfere with secession, and negotiations begin on the disposition of “public property” with seceded states.
-February 8th, A provisional confederated government and draft constitution is formally established in Montgomery Alabama by 6 independent states. (Texas Delegates in transit)
-US President Buchanan’s original armistice agreement to evacuate federal troops from all forts by February 9th, expires, he has informed former President Tyler’s Peace Commission that he now has no intention of evacuating the remaining occupation troops from the 7 newly confederated states. (Act of War)
-February 11th, Jefferson Davis is inaugurated as provisional President of the 7 Confederate States of America.
-February 13th, The U.S. Congress met in a Joint Session to count the Electoral College votes to certify the results of 1860 presidential election, the most highly contested in American history.
-February 16th, The Republic of Texas begins seizing forts and armories within its boarders after secession, and subsequently joining the C.S.A.
-February 18th, U.S. President Buchanan ordered a Naval Squadron sent to Florida with reinforcements for Fort Pickens however, is only allowed to resupply, not permitted to land troops in accordance with Buchanan’s armistice with Florida’s Governor Perry.
-February 22nd, The new Government of the Confederate States of America (CSA) has now assumed delegated authority for the coastal defenses of seven member states, with consent of the Governors.
-February 23, The Baltimore Plot”;
Rumors circulate of a plan to assassinate Abraham Lincoln, the most Unpopular President in American history, as he travels through Baltimore Maryland, on his way to Washington D.C., for his inauguration.
-February 27th, C.S. President Davis has requested commissioners to be sent to Europe to establish diplomatic relations, and names three C.S. commissioners to be sent to Washington DC to negotiate peaceful relations with the U.S. Government.

Misunderstanding Both Lincoln and Basic Economics

by Allen C. Guelzo
Alfred A. Knopf, 2024; 247 pp.

Allen Guelzo has been carried away by Abraham Lincoln’s magniloquent rhetoric. Guelzo, a historian who has written a number of books about Lincoln, would like very much to believe that his hero was a champion of individual rights and economic freedom. Lincoln’s ideal for America was of a nation with a large number of small businesses, allowing people to work independently of domination by others. Slavery was the supreme denial of this ideal and, as such, abhorrent to him. In a phrase Guelzo often repeats, Lincoln wanted an America with “neither slaves, nor masters.” In this America, blacks would have the same citizenship

Further, Guelzo claims, the complaints against Lincoln from his detractors are wrong. During the War between the States, he did not act as a dictator, ruthlessly suppressing opposition; to the contrary, he acted with caution, anxious to avoid violating the Constitution. Guelzo has done me the honor of quoting me, but I was wrong to draw a parallel between Lincoln and his slightly younger contemporary, Otto von Bismarck. Unlike the great German Chancellor, Lincoln was not a “ruthless manufacturer of a modern Wohlfahrtsstaat (welfare state).” He did, however, realize that secession was a principle of anarchy: constitutional democracy could not survive if it was allowed. Moreover, his military action against the South was a response to its violent insurrection and rebellion. One suspects that he would agree with Edward Everett, who in his oration at Gettysburg in 1863 spoke of the secessionist leaders as “bold, bad men.”

Guelzo has the merit of raising a fundamental issue, but it is one about which he is mistaken. He thinks that a “democratic order cannot survive if large parts of society conclude that they will walk away whenever they are displeased with the result—or, in this case, not even walk away, but assault federal property (namely, Fort Sumter).” The obvious question to ask Guelzo is “Why can’t it survive?” Wouldn’t the “democratic order” remain as it was before the secession but with less territory? If the response is that people could secede from the smaller state, what is wrong with that? If Guelzo thinks that it’s bad that states fall below a minimum size, and—as I don’t believe—he’s right, why wouldn’t those who contemplate secession be deterred from doing so by its bad consequences?

So far as Lincoln’s devotion to freedom is concerned, Guelzo is constrained to admit:

What Lincoln seemed to find most objectionable about Southern demands to admit slavery to the rest of the western territories was not their racial tyranny, but the likelihood that legalizing slavery would cut off access to those territories . . . for white farmers who would not be able to rival the economies of scale enjoyed by slave-gang labor. . . . He certainly had no desire in the 1850s to tamper with slavery in the existing slave states. Although Lincoln had often repeated his hope for the “ultimate extinction of the institution,” he clarified “ultimate” to mean somewhere off in the far, far distance.

So far as the reference to the 1850s is concerned, it should be noted that, as Thomas DiLorenzo has shown, Lincoln not only endorsed but was a behind-the-scenes promoter of the Corwin Amendment, which would have locked into the Constitution a guarantee against interference with slavery in the states where it already existed.

Guelzo also agrees with DiLorenzo that Lincoln was a devoted disciple of Henry Clay and his “American System,” though the two authors look upon this from very different perspectives. Lincoln sought to build up industry through supporting “internal improvements” and tariff protection for products he favored; this “support” was frequently characterized by corruption. Guelzo notes that the Jeffersonians opposed these measures, but he presents the clash between them and the supporters of the American System in a misleading way. As he sees it, the Jeffersonians hated industry and cities, preferring “neo-feudal agrarianism” to the urban democratic culture, where every man had a chance to get ahead. The real contrast lies elsewhere, between those who thought that economic development—whether industrial or agricultural—took place better through the free decisions of individuals and those who thought it took place better through control by the state.

Guelzo fails to see that answering the question of economic development requires the study of economic principles, such as the law of comparative advantage, which are the discoveries of a value-free science. He instead looks at the tariff issue as a contrast between the agricultural and industrial “interests.” America needed tariffs to build up its nascent industries until they could fend for themselves. Britain, which had already built up its industrial might, rightly repealed the Corn Laws. “In both cases, the strategy was aimed at a hostile and reactionary agrarianism.” Our confidence in Guelzo’s knowledge of the history of economic thought does not increase when we read, “Herndon identifies John Ramsay McCulloch, rather than [Adam] Smith, as one of Lincoln’s models, which is odd, since McCulloch followed the lead of David Ricardo and particularly questioned any labor theory of value.” Both Ricardo and McCulloch were strong proponents of the labor theory of value.

Although Guelzo has read very widely, his knowledge of philosophy is often deficient and his arguments unsound. For example, he says:

The Enlightenment began as a scientific revolt against the hierarchical notions of the physical universe as taught by Aristotelian scholastics. Rather than seeing all objects imbedded in a “great chain” of occult relationships that stretched from the base earth to the spotless heavens, all those relationships now appeared in the testimony of Galileo and Newton as individual entities, in no necessary order or relationship to each other, and moved only by measurable and predictable natural forces.

What is supposed to be the inconsistency in believing both that objects are governed by occult relationships and that individual entities are governed by measurable and predictable laws? Newton believed both. Far from thinking that individual entities are governed “only” by mechanical relationships, he thought that God needed to intervene in the solar system from time to time and that absolute space was God’s sensorium. It’s quite true that later physicists don’t hold these views, but nevertheless Newton did, and this did not prevent him from being rather good at science.

Immanuel Kant is a notoriously difficult writer, and there are many conflicting interpretations of his thought. For this reason, we should judge what Guelzo says about him charitably, but even if we do so, we cannot avoid the conclusion that he does not know what he is talking about. He says:

Reason had no greater admirer than Immanuel Kant, and yet even Kant warned that reason made mistakes that experience did little to correct. The reasoning mind could deal only with the appearances of things, not the things-in-themselves, which required an entirely different way of knowing, apart from reason. . . . However, Kant believed, tools did exist with which to penetrate and apprehend those underlying realities; one was criticism, another was intuition.

Lincoln As He Really Was Charles T Pace, Thomas…Best Price: $23.39Buy New $19.95(as of 11:10 UTC – Details)Kant most assuredly does not believe that human beings can obtain knowledge of things-in-themselves. He does think that the moral law, the product of “pure practical reason,” makes it rational to postulate God, freedom, and immortality, but this does not amount to knowledge, which for human beings is limited to the phenomenal world. I don’t know what Guelzo could mean by saying that “criticism” enables us “to penetrate and apprehend these underlying realities”; a main project of the Critique of Pure Reason is to show that human beings do not have such knowledge. Human beings do not know things-in-themselves by intuition; only God has an intellectual intuition of things-in-themselves.

If anything, Guelzo’s account of John Rawls is even worse. He says that Lincoln’s second inaugural address “was not Rawlsian relativism. He [Lincoln] was inviting, not the descent of a veil of ignorance about the right or wrong of slavery, but a pure confession of guilt from the limited, stumbling, blind, and wrong-headed folly of all parties.” Later in the book, Guelzo says that “Rawls believed that ‘deeply opposed though reasonable comprehensive doctrines may live together and all affirm the political conception of a constitutional regime’ because no questions of that nature were really of compelling significance . . . he [Lincoln] could not tolerate indifference to slavery itself.”

This is risibly inept. Rawls wouldn’t count a comprehensive doctrine that accepted slavery as reasonable. All of the reasonable doctrines are supposed to converge on accepting Rawls’s two principles of justice—the first of which, the liberty principle, excludes slavery. There are many excellent reasons to reject Rawls’s theory, but Guelzo’s ludicrous misrepresentations of it aren’t among them.

Let us return from philosophy to Lincoln bashing. Our principal grievance against Lincoln is that he was responsible for a horrendous and destructive war that could have been averted had he accepted peaceful separation. Lincoln spoke of “malice toward none” and “charity for all,” but his actions belied his words.

Note: The views expressed on Mises.org are not necessarily those of the Mises Institute.